| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Eric Vandervlugt | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Stefan Ghodino | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Andy Aupin defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Gannon McSween defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Tony Nguyen defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Mike Patrowicz defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Joe Theriault | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Chris Bartha defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Ken Defilippis defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| John Desjardins defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 Mens Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Randy Fawcett defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 Mens Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Steve Scobie | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Chris Wood defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Marc Godin defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Brandyn Griffin | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Bobby Drowns | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Dave Lettner defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Pod Shognosh defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Peter Hetherington defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Justin Daniliunas defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Russ Cormier | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Kevin Oliveira | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Jesse Piercey | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Marco Devilla defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Brad Guthrie defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Cody Ward | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Ben Heywood defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Randy Strong defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Denise Belanger defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Jeff Pollock defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Alex Radomski defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| A.J. Tibayan defeated Scot Noonan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Cody Ward defeated A.J. Tibayan | 2011 404 Tour 9-Ball |