| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Grace Nakamura defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2010 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Rob Blair defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2010 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Aaryn Sheahan defeated Ken Cannon | 2010 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Aaryn Sheahan defeated Joe Theriault | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Chris Orme defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Aaryn Sheahan defeated George Cornelius | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Aaryn Sheahan defeated Jeet Kandhai | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Tol Kuy defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Brad Lucas defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Nick Toulis defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Ronald Giron defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Aaryn Sheahan defeated Dave Kirby | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Darlene Gardiner defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Ben Chang defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2008 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Nito Bucais defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2008 404 Tour 9-Ball |