| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Scott Norton defeated Andrew Pettenger | 2024 Piazza's - NYE Ball 12/31/2023 MIXED |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Scott Norton | 2024 Piazza's - NYE Ball 12/31/2023 MIXED |
| Scott Norton defeated Andrew Pettenger | 2024 Piazza's - NYE Ball 12/31/2023 MIXED |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Russ Green | 2023 Piazza's - NYE Ball 12/31/2023 MIXED |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Robert Figueroa | 2023 Piazza's - NYE Ball 12/31/2023 MIXED |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Rich Chan | 2023 Piazza's - NYE Ball 12/31/2023 MIXED |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Charles Mora | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Billy Dyke | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Josh Roberts | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Mike Duke | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Joseph Henry | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Chris Robinson defeated Andrew Pettenger | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Kevin West | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Tommy Tokoph defeated Andrew Pettenger | 2018 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Steve Lillis | 2013 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Andrew Pettenger defeated Ernesto Contrera | 2013 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Oscar Dominguez defeated Andrew Pettenger | 2013 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Imran Majid defeated Andrew Pettenger | 2013 U.S.Open 9-Ball |