| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Bernard Walker defeated Arthur Macdonald | 2014 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Arthur Macdonald defeated Vincent Rochefort | 2019 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Scooby Pelton defeated Arthur Macdonald | 2019 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Anthony LaRue defeated Arthur Macdonald | 2022 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Arthur Macdonald defeated Bobby Powell | 2022 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |