| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Jennifer Bush | 2023 TopShots Women's 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Beverly Knibb | 2023 TopShots Women's 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Jennifer Sheppard | 2023 TopShots Women's 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Jamie Porth | 2023 TopShots Women's 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Tannis Clarke | 2023 TopShots Women's 8-Ball |
| Allison Fisher defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2019 WPBA Masters 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Catherine Tschumper | 2019 WPBA Masters 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Dawn Hopkins | 2019 WPBA Masters 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Melissa Little | 2019 WPBA Masters 9-Ball |
| Kristina Tkach defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2019 WPBA Masters 9-Ball |
| Hiroko Makiyama defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2019 WPBA BLU-EMU Southern Open II Signature Tour Stop 9-Ball |
| Melissa Little defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2019 WPBA BLU-EMU Southern Open II Signature Tour Stop 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Angela Janic | 2019 WPBA BLU-EMU Southern Open II Signature Tour Stop 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Bonnie Arnold | 2019 WPBA BLU-EMU Southern Open II Signature Tour Stop 9-Ball |
| Maria Juana defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2019 WPBA Aramith/DR Pool Classic 9-Ball |
| Wei Tzu Chien defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2019 WPBA Aramith/DR Pool Classic 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated April Larson | 2019 WPBA Aramith/DR Pool Classic 9-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Susie Wipper | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Joanne Ashton | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Naomi Williams defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Grace Nakamura defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Brittany Bryant | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Kayla Jones defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Leanne Lini | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Kristy Rinalli | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Cathy Metzinger defeated Maureen Seto | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Brittany Bryant defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2008 Womens Canadian Championships 8-Ball |
| Nathalie Jacob defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2005 Womens Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Anita Kuczma defeated Cathy Metzinger | 2005 Womens Canadian Championships 9-Ball |