| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Stuart Mann defeated Craig Butler | 2005 World Championship Snooker |
| Brian Morgan defeated Craig Butler | 2005 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Lee Walker | 2005 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Mark Gray | 2005 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Jimmy Michie defeated Craig Butler | 2005 Malta Cup Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Brian Salmon | 2005 Malta Cup Snooker |
| Ben Woollaston defeated Craig Butler | 2005 Irish Masters Snooker |
| Gary Wilkinson defeated Craig Butler | 2005 China Open Snooker |
| Darren Morgan defeated Craig Butler | 2004 World Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Tom Ford | 2004 World Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Brian Salmon | 2004 World Championship Snooker |
| Dave Finbow defeated Craig Butler | 2004 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Joe Delaney | 2004 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Supoj Saenla | 2004 Welsh Open Snooker |
| David McDonnell defeated Craig Butler | 2004 UK Championship Snooker |
| Kurt Maflin defeated Craig Butler | 2004 Players Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Gary Hardiman | 2004 Players Championship Snooker |
| Ding Junhui defeated Craig Butler | 2004 Irish Masters Snooker |
| Sean Storey defeated Craig Butler | 2004 Grand Prix Snooker |
| David Roe defeated Craig Butler | 2004 European Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Michael Rhodes | 2004 European Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Supoj Saenla | 2004 European Open Snooker |
| Joe Jogia defeated Craig Butler | 2004 British Open Snooker |
| Andy Hicks defeated Craig Butler | 2003 World Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Munraj Pal | 2003 World Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Ricky Walden | 2003 World Championship Snooker |
| Robert Milkins defeated Craig Butler | 2003 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Nick Walker | 2003 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Johl Younger | 2003 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Jimmy Robertson | 2003 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Neil Robertson defeated Craig Butler | 2003 UK Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Scott MacKenzie | 2003 UK Championship Snooker |
| David John defeated Craig Butler | 2003 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Jamie Cope defeated Craig Butler | 2003 Masters Qualifying Event Snooker |
| Alfie Burden defeated Craig Butler | 2003 LG Cup Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Stephen Croft | 2003 LG Cup Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Chris Melling | 2003 LG Cup Snooker |
| Nick Dyson defeated Craig Butler | 2003 Irish Masters Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Antony Bolsover | 2003 Irish Masters Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Nick Pearce | 2003 Irish Masters Snooker |
| Stuart Pettman defeated Craig Butler | 2003 European Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Simon Bedford | 2003 European Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Manan Chandra | 2003 European Open Snooker |
| Stuart Bingham defeated Craig Butler | 2003 British Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Sean Storey | 2003 British Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Philip Williams | 2003 British Open Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Paul Sweeny | 2003 British Open Snooker |
| Robin Hull defeated Craig Butler | 2002 World Championship Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Martin Gould | 2002 World Championship Snooker |
| Stephen Kershaw defeated Craig Butler | 2002 Welsh Open Snooker |