| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Mike Smith defeated David Butler | 2024 Corner Pocket 2021 Every Saturday Night Open #2 Fargo Handicapped 9bal 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Cody Gragg | 2023 New Years Eve Eve Fargo 23 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Todd Speakman | 2023 New Years Eve Eve Fargo 23 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated James Harris | 2023 New Years Eve Eve Fargo 23 9-Ball |
| Gigi Callejas defeated David Butler | 2023 New Years Eve Eve Fargo 23 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Carlos B Castillo Jr | 2023 New Years Eve Eve Fargo 23 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Ed Lloyd Gragg | 2023 Corner Pocket Saturday Night Open #14 9ball Fargo Handicapped--Christm 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Walid Rahman | 2023 Corner Pocket Saturday Night Open #14 9ball Fargo Handicapped--Christm 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Ed Lloyd Gragg | 2023 Corner Pocket Saturday Night Open #14 9ball Fargo Handicapped--Christm 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Walid Rahman | 2023 Corner Pocket Saturday Night Open #14 9ball Fargo Handicapped--Christm 9-Ball |
| David Butler defeated Samuel Shikaloff | 2023 Corner Pocket Saturday Night Open #14 9ball Fargo Handicapped--Christm 9-Ball |
| Suppachai Wiwattrangkoon defeated David Butler | 2001 World Championship Snooker |
| Craig Steadman defeated David Butler | 2000 World Championship Snooker |
| Nick Smith defeated David Butler | 1999 World Championship Snooker |
| Stephen Maguire defeated David Butler | 1998 World Championship Snooker |