| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| John Tate defeated Edgar Shuck | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Tim Heath defeated Edgar Shuck | 2017 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Sean King defeated Edgar Shuck | 2017 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Roberto Frost defeated Edgar Shuck | 2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Bobby McGrath defeated Edgar Shuck | 2014 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Shannon Murphy defeated Edgar Shuck | 2014 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Edgar Shuck defeated Gardner Washburn | 2013 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Edgar Shuck defeated LaMoine Hammer | 2013 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Aaron Toth defeated Edgar Shuck | 2013 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joseph Gray defeated Edgar Shuck | 2012 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |