| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Tom Zippler defeated Frank Gaetani | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Michael Yednak defeated Frank Gaetani | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Petri Makkonen defeated Frank Gaetani | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Frank Gaetani defeated Bryan Martell | 2024 Hampden County's February 10-Ball |
| Frank Gaetani defeated Robert Poulin | 2024 Hampden County's February 10-Ball |
| Fred Steinberg defeated Frank Gaetani | 2024 Hampden County's February 10-Ball |