| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| April Dobbins defeated Heather Middleton | 2024 Music City 2024 Ladies Nine Ball 9-Ball |
| Heather Middleton defeated Brenda Anderson | 2024 Music City 2024 Ladies Nine Ball 9-Ball |
| Christina Perlowski defeated Heather Middleton | 2024 Music City 2024 Ladies Nine Ball 9-Ball |
| Heather Middleton defeated Kim Dodd | 2024 Music City 2024 Ladies Nine Ball 9-Ball |
| Heather Middleton defeated Briana Edwards | 2019 Womens Music City 9-Ball |
| Heather Middleton defeated Keira Graves | 2019 Womens Music City 9-Ball |
| Heather Middleton defeated Angela Gann | 2019 Womens Music City 9-Ball |
| Brittany Bryant defeated Heather Middleton | 2019 Womens Music City 9-Ball |
| Julie Cooper defeated Heather Middleton | 2019 Womens Music City 9-Ball |
| Heather Middleton defeated Karen Pollard | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Teresa Garland defeated Heather Middleton | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Heather Middleton defeated Kelly Jones | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Heather Middleton defeated Lisa Cossette | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Heather Middleton defeated Pauline Mattes | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Jennifer Berzinski defeated Heather Middleton | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |