| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Errick Tamoria defeated Jeff Gardner | 2024 Livingston's Weekly 1/5 9-Ball |
| Roberto Jimenez defeated Jeff Gardner | 2024 Livingston's Weekly 1/5 9-Ball |
| Jeff Gardner defeated Richard Rothstein | 2024 Livingston's Weekly 1/5 9-Ball |
| Jeff Gardner defeated Jim Jablonski | 2024 Livingston's Weekly 1/5 9-Ball |
| Jonathan Hunter defeated Jeff Gardner | 2024 Livingston's Weekly 1/12 9-Ball |
| David Zabell defeated Jeff Gardner | 2024 Livingston's Weekly 1/12 9-Ball |
| Matt Winchester defeated Jeff Gardner | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/29 9-Ball |
| Kyle Bigos defeated Jeff Gardner | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/29 9-Ball |
| Jeff Gardner defeated Goran Nikolov | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/22 9-Ball |
| Errick Tamoria defeated Jeff Gardner | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/22 9-Ball |
| Steve Knoll defeated Jeff Gardner | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/22 9-Ball |
| Jeff Gardner defeated Craig Sheffield | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/22 9-Ball |
| Roberto Halabi defeated Jeff Gardner | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/15 9-Ball |
| Jeff Gardner defeated Tim Wotherspoon | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/15 9-Ball |
| Lee Heuwagen defeated Jeff Gardner | 2023 Livingston's Weekly 12/15 9-Ball |