| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Lawrence Everson defeated Joe Gay | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Ike Runnels defeated Joe Gay | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Coen Bell | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Anton Washington | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Veronika Ivanovskaia | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Ben Smith defeated Joe Gay | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Justin Bergman defeated Joe Gay | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Charlie Guilfoyle | 2019 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Eric Kwon | 2019 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Ed Hobbs defeated Joe Gay | 2019 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| T.J. Back defeated Joe Gay | 2019 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Chris Frederick | 2018 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| John Lankswert defeated Joe Gay | 2018 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Terry Zurface | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Michael Eck defeated Joe Gay | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Mieszko Fortunski defeated Joe Gay | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Clay Carman | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Roberto Gomez defeated Joe Gay | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Drake Niepoetter defeated Joe Gay | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Sergio Rivas defeated Joe Gay | 2017 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| John Meyers defeated Joe Gay | 2017 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Timothy Mastroianni | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Ken Jordan defeated Joe Gay | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Kenny Tran defeated Joe Gay | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Raymond Galaviz | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Mike Smith | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Tom Paulowske defeated Joe Gay | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Darren Appleton defeated Joe Gay | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Danny Smith defeated Joe Gay | 2015 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Mike Johnson | 2015 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Glenn Rogers | 2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Michael Hughes defeated Joe Gay | 2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Jim Griffith defeated Joe Gay | 2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Russ Morgan | 2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Rudy Maybin defeated Joe Gay | 2014 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Ivan Sweezer defeated Joe Gay | 2014 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Larry Nevel defeated Joe Gay | 2014 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Gay defeated Ted Reeves | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Jason Woosley | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Jerry Matchin defeated Joe Gay | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Larry Nevel defeated Joe Gay | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Clent McCullough defeated Joe Gay | 2012 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Joe Gay defeated Mike Martin | 2012 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Shawn Putnam defeated Joe Gay | 2012 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Buddy Hall defeated Joe Gay | 1998 Legends Of One Pocket |