| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Tommy Shipp defeated John Plumlee | 2024 SHERMAN VFW TEXOMA SHOOTOUT - 13/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| Kaitlyn Brown defeated John Plumlee | 2024 SHERMAN VFW TEXOMA SHOOTOUT - 13/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Ron Westenhaver | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 7/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated James Autrey | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 7/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Tim Grunst | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 7/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Tony Brown | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 7/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Dustin Potter | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 7/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| James Autrey defeated John Plumlee | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 7/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| Brandon Sisemore defeated John Plumlee | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Joseph Geesling | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Lucah Gianino | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Corri Goncalvez | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Alejandro Villegas | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Gene Joslin | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Gene Joslin | 2024 SHERMAN VFW - 5/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| David Gonzales defeated John Plumlee | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 2/JAN/24 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Jeffrey Franklin | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 2/JAN/24 8-Ball |
| Tom Smith defeated John Plumlee | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 2/JAN/24 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Tommy Wilkerson | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 2/JAN/24 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Gene Joslin | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 2/JAN/24 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Phillip Wilson | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 2/JAN/24 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Steve Langston | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 16/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Phillip Wilson | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 16/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Diana Bodeker | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 16/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| Tommy Wilkerson defeated John Plumlee | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 16/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| Trey Salisbury defeated John Plumlee | 2024 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 16/JAN/23 8-Ball |
| Jeffrey Franklin defeated John Plumlee | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 26/DEC/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Kathryn Musick | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 26/DEC/23 8-Ball |
| Steve Langston defeated John Plumlee | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 26/DEC/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Max Ochs | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 26/DEC/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Bre Hillin | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 26/DEC/23 8-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Justin Lasiter | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 21/DEC/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Brandon Oglesby | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 21/DEC/23 9-Ball |
| Steve Thompson defeated John Plumlee | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 21/DEC/23 9-Ball |
| Rodney Buchanan defeated John Plumlee | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 21/DEC/23 9-Ball |
| John Plumlee defeated Kaleb Johnston | 2023 DENISON AMERICAN LEGION - 21/DEC/23 9-Ball |
| Randall Rump defeated John Plumlee | 2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |