| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Earl Herring defeated John Vitale | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| Matt Krah defeated John Vitale | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Nate Marshall | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Bud Robideau | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Nick Coppola | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| Joshua Oneal defeated John Vitale | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Clay Rhinehart defeated John Vitale | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| John Vitale defeated Thomas Hollis | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Bille Miller | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Matt Krah defeated John Vitale | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Thorsten Hohmann defeated John Vitale | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Eric Clouthier defeated John Vitale | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Brian Lipes | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Richard Jones | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Kevin Ketz defeated John Vitale | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Nathan Puckett defeated John Vitale | 2015 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| John Vitale defeated Chris Spade | 2015 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Justin Daniliunas defeated John Vitale | 2014 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Jeremy Seaman defeated John Vitale | 2014 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |