| Stephen Aylesworth defeated Junior Mergenthaler |
2013 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Stewart Kenney defeated Junior Mergenthaler |
2014 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Alex Montpellier defeated Junior Mergenthaler |
2015 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Junior Mergenthaler defeated John Gaskin |
2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Joe Villalpando defeated Junior Mergenthaler |
2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Matt Mccall defeated Junior Mergenthaler |
2017 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Junior Mergenthaler defeated Delano Buchanan |
2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Steve Anderson defeated Junior Mergenthaler |
2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |