| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Eddie Barker defeated Karl Broughton | 2004 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Rene van Rijsbergen | 2004 World Championship Snooker |
| Daniel Rathbone defeated Karl Broughton | 2004 Challenge Tour - Event 4 Snooker |
| Andrew Pagett defeated Karl Broughton | 2004 Challenge Tour - Event 3 Snooker |
| Nick Pearce defeated Karl Broughton | 2003 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Andrew Milliard | 2003 World Championship Snooker |
| Ian Martin defeated Karl Broughton | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 4 Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Lee Farebrother | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 4 Snooker |
| Robert Murphy defeated Karl Broughton | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 3 Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated David Hall | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 3 Snooker |
| Rene van Rijsbergen defeated Karl Broughton | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 2 Snooker |
| Steve Meakin defeated Karl Broughton | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 2 Snooker |
| Matthew Selt defeated Karl Broughton | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 1 Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Declan Lavery | 2003 Challenge Tour - Event 1 Snooker |
| Ryan Day defeated Karl Broughton | 2002 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Eddie Manning | 2002 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Del Smith | 2002 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Pang Weiguo | 2002 World Championship Snooker |
| Paul Sweeny defeated Karl Broughton | 2002 Challenge Tour - Event 4 Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Reind Duut | 2002 Challenge Tour - Event 4 Snooker |
| Kuldesh Johal defeated Karl Broughton | 2002 Challenge Tour - Event 3 Snooker |
| Tom Ford defeated Karl Broughton | 2002 Challenge Tour - Event 1 Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Edward Davies | 2002 Challenge Tour - Event 1 Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Kelly Fisher | 2002 Challenge Tour - Event 1 Snooker |
| Craig Butler defeated Karl Broughton | 2001 World Championship Snooker |
| James Reynolds defeated Karl Broughton | 2001 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Michael Judge defeated Karl Broughton | 2001 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Rod Lawler | 2001 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Tony Knowles | 2001 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Robin Hull defeated Karl Broughton | 2001 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Dylan Leary defeated Karl Broughton | 2001 Challenge Tour - Event 2 Snooker |
| Jamie Burnett defeated Karl Broughton | 2001 Benson and Hedges Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Suppachai Wiwattrangkoon | 2001 Benson and Hedges Championship Snooker |
| Bradley Jones defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Gareth Chilcott | 2000 World Championship Snooker |
| Nick Dyson defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 Welsh Open Snooker |
| David Gray defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 UK Championship Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Munraj Pal | 2000 UK Championship Snooker |
| Nick Dyson defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Anthony Hamilton defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Jason Prince | 2000 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Mario Geudens | 2000 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Alfie Burden defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 Malta Grand Prix Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Jason Ferguson | 2000 Malta Grand Prix Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Wayne Saidler | 2000 Malta Grand Prix Snooker |
| David McLellan defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 Grand Prix Snooker |
| Antony Bolsover defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 China Open Snooker |
| Gary Ponting defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 British Open Snooker |
| Karl Broughton defeated Antony Bolsover | 2000 British Open Snooker |
| Billy Snaddon defeated Karl Broughton | 2000 Benson and Hedges Championship Snooker |