| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Joe Grech defeated Karl Payne | 1999 World Championship Snooker |
| Tony Knowles defeated Karl Payne | 1999 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Stephen Maguire defeated Karl Payne | 1999 UK Tour - Event 4 Snooker |
| Leo Fernandez defeated Karl Payne | 1999 UK Tour - Event 3 Snooker |
| Neal Foulds defeated Karl Payne | 1999 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Paul McPhillips | 1999 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Dave Harold defeated Karl Payne | 1999 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Mark Davis | 1999 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Joe Grech | 1999 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Alan Burnett defeated Karl Payne | 1999 China International Snooker |
| Antony Bolsover defeated Karl Payne | 1999 British Open Snooker |
| Stefan Mazrocis defeated Karl Payne | 1998 World Championship Snooker |
| Stefan Mazrocis defeated Karl Payne | 1998 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Jeff Cundy defeated Karl Payne | 1998 UK Championship Snooker |
| Chris Scanlon defeated Karl Payne | 1998 Thailand Masters Snooker |
| Ronnie O'Sullivan defeated Karl Payne | 1998 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Dennis Taylor | 1998 Scottish Open Snooker |
| Tony Knowles defeated Karl Payne | 1998 Irish Open Snooker |
| Shokat Ali defeated Karl Payne | 1998 Grand Prix Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Chris Shade | 1998 Grand Prix Snooker |
| Matthew Stevens defeated Karl Payne | 1998 British Open Snooker |
| Tony Knowles defeated Karl Payne | 1998 Benson and Hedges Championship Snooker |
| Stefan Mazrocis defeated Karl Payne | 1997 World Championship Snooker |
| Michael Judge defeated Karl Payne | 1997 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Shokat Ali defeated Karl Payne | 1997 UK Championship Snooker |
| Jimmy Michie defeated Karl Payne | 1997 Thailand Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Les Dodd | 1997 Thailand Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Joe Grech | 1997 Qualifying School - Event 2 Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Ian Brumby | 1997 Qualifying School - Event 2 Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated David McDonnell | 1997 Qualifying School - Event 2 Snooker |
| Sean Lanigan defeated Karl Payne | 1997 Qualifying School - Event 1 Snooker |
| Oliver King defeated Karl Payne | 1997 International Open Snooker |
| Anthony Davies defeated Karl Payne | 1997 Grand Prix Snooker |
| Quinten Hann defeated Karl Payne | 1997 German Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Stefan Mazrocis | 1997 German Open Snooker |
| Michael Duffy defeated Karl Payne | 1997 European Open Snooker |
| Joe Perry defeated Karl Payne | 1997 British Open Snooker |
| Joe Perry defeated Karl Payne | 1997 Benson and Hedges Championship Snooker |
| Dave Finbow defeated Karl Payne | 1996 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Barry Pinches | 1996 World Championship Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Ian Bullimore | 1996 World Championship Snooker |
| Dave Harold defeated Karl Payne | 1996 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Jason Ferguson | 1996 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Nigel Gilbert | 1996 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Troy Shaw | 1996 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Gary Lees | 1996 Welsh Open Snooker |
| Robert Milkins defeated Karl Payne | 1996 UK Championship Snooker |
| Stuart Pettman defeated Karl Payne | 1996 Thailand Open Snooker |
| Karl Payne defeated Michael Duffy | 1996 Thailand Open Snooker |
| Nigel Bond defeated Karl Payne | 1996 International Open Snooker |