| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Larry Phelgar defeated Marc Dionne | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Mark Creamer defeated Larry Phelgar | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Matt Tetreault defeated Larry Phelgar | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Charles Mora defeated Larry Phelgar | 2015 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| John Cook defeated Larry Phelgar | 2015 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| David Ricci defeated Larry Phelgar | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Chris Tiru defeated Larry Phelgar | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Larry Phelgar defeated Randy Russell | 2014 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| John Pinegar defeated Larry Phelgar | 2014 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| John Schmidt defeated Larry Phelgar | 2014 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Eric Durbin defeated Larry Phelgar | 2013 Ultimate Championship 10-Ball |
| Justin Hall defeated Larry Phelgar | 2013 Ultimate Championship 10-Ball |
| Darren Appleton defeated Larry Phelgar | 2013 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Paul Spaanstra defeated Larry Phelgar | 2013 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Mark Haddad defeated Larry Phelgar | 2012 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Masato Yoshioka defeated Larry Phelgar | 2012 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Matt Krah defeated Larry Phelgar | 2011 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| David Fernandez defeated Larry Phelgar | 2011 U.S.Open 9-Ball |