| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Michael Malone defeated Larry Phlegar | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Lee Van Corteza defeated Larry Phlegar | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Nilbert Lim defeated Larry Phlegar | 2017 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Elias Patrikios defeated Larry Phlegar | 2017 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Willey Oney defeated Larry Phlegar | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Paul Roeraade defeated Larry Phlegar | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| Fred Gokey defeated Larry Phlegar | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |