| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Matt Gillingham defeated Jeffrey Cho | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Matt Gillingham defeated George Bone Jr | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Michael Deitchman defeated Matt Gillingham | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Matt Gillingham defeated Thomas Kirsch | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Mika Immonen defeated Matt Gillingham | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Matt Gillingham defeated Nabil Lazouzi | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Nicolas Charette defeated Matt Gillingham | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Che Lemmon defeated Matt Gillingham | 2019 Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Jason Williams defeated Matt Gillingham | 2019 Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Brian Flynn defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 East Coast Canadian Open 9-Ball |
| Corey Deuel defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 East Coast Canadian Open 9-Ball |
| Steve Hipson defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 East Coast Canadian Open 8-Ball |
| Rob Millard defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 East Coast Canadian Open 8-Ball |
| TJ Humber defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Paul Tytler defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Matt Gillingham defeated Wekatesk Augustine | 2018 Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Brian Massender defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 Amateur Canadian Championships 10-Ball |
| Ian Argue defeated Matt Gillingham | 2018 Amateur Canadian Championships 10-Ball |
| Matt Gillingham defeated Dan Buchanan | 2017 East Coast Canadian Open 9-Ball |
| Wayne Gallant defeated Matt Gillingham | 2017 East Coast Canadian Open 9-Ball |
| Matt Gillingham defeated Andrew Sprague | 2017 East Coast Canadian Open 9-Ball |
| Carl Sampson defeated Matt Gillingham | 2017 East Coast Canadian Open 9-Ball |