| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Hunter Lombardo defeated Michael Toohig | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| Robert Hart defeated Michael Toohig | 2024 Turning Stone Classic XXXVIII 9-Ball |
| Barry Koller defeated Michael Toohig | 2022 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Patrick Roy defeated Michael Toohig | 2022 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Kenny Seitz defeated Michael Toohig | 2022 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Konrad Juszczyszyn defeated Michael Toohig | 2022 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Matt Krah defeated Michael Toohig | 2022 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Michael Toohig defeated Luis Carreon | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Mikael Hinton defeated Michael Toohig | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Frank Ruby defeated Michael Toohig | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Cody Myers defeated Michael Toohig | 2020 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Michael Toohig defeated Steve Morrow | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Phillips Yee defeated Michael Toohig | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Rob Hart defeated Michael Toohig | 2020 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Michael Toohig defeated Robert Ragusa | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Tommy Tokoph defeated Michael Toohig | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Tom Gildea defeated Michael Toohig | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Michael Toohig defeated Rich Connors | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Donny Mills defeated Michael Toohig | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Michael Toohig defeated Chris Tiru | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| David Ricci defeated Michael Toohig | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Tom D'Alfonso defeated Michael Toohig | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |