| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Will Thomsen defeated Mike Athens | 2023 Ship the Cheese Mid Roller 9-Ball |
| Mike Athens defeated Jimmy Nosavan | 2023 Ship the Cheese Mid Roller 9-Ball |
| Steve Boucher defeated Mike Athens | 2023 Ship the Cheese Mid Roller 9-Ball |
| Mike Athens defeated Scott Blake | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Brian Wilson defeated Mike Athens | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Dee Adkins defeated Mike Athens | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Mike Athens defeated Brian Edwards | 2019 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Mike Athens defeated Jason Miller | 2019 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Edward Hancock defeated Mike Athens | 2019 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Mohammad Ali Berjaoui defeated Mike Athens | 2019 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Issa Eadeh defeated Mike Athens | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Mike Athens defeated Gary Muzzillo | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Mike Athens defeated J.D. Dolan | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Shane McMinn defeated Mike Athens | 2017 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Miguel Laboy defeated Mike Athens | 2017 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Justin Hall defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Mike Athens defeated Brett Underwood | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Mike Athens defeated Don Stiles | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Bill Rosenbaum defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Jordan Jenquin defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Mike Athens defeated Dave Bremer | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Mike Athens defeated Alex Montpellier | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Jeremy Sossei defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Joseph Tourangeau defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |