| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Efren Reyes defeated Mike Sigel | Ultimate Showdown Bank Pool |
| Mike Sigel defeated Unknown Player | The Baltimore Bullet Movie |
| Mike Sigel defeated Unknown Player | 8-Ball, 9-Ball & Straight Pool Instructional |
| Mike Sigel defeated Unknown Player | 8-Ball, 9-Ball & Straight Pool Instructional |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge Straight Pool |
| Mike Sigel defeated Earl Strickland | 2018 Living Legends Challenge Straight Pool |
| Mike Sigel defeated Earl Strickland | 2018 Living Legends Challenge One Pocket |
| Mike Sigel defeated Earl Strickland | 2018 Living Legends Challenge One Pocket |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge Bank Pool |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge 9-Ball |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge 8-Ball |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge 8-Ball |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge 10-Ball |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 2018 Living Legends Challenge 10-Ball |
| Askild Hansen defeated Mike Sigel | 2010 EuroTour French Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Thomasz Kaplan | 2010 EuroTour French Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Ralf Mrnka | 2010 EuroTour French Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Maximilian Hetjens | 2010 EuroTour French Open 9-Ball |
| Harald Stolka defeated Mike Sigel | 2010 EuroTour French Open 9-Ball |
| Danny DiLiberto defeated Mike Sigel | 2008 Danny DiLiberto - Legend of Pool Documentary |
| Efren Reyes defeated Mike Sigel | 2005 King of the Hill 8-Ball |
| Efren Reyes defeated Mike Sigel | 2005 King of the Hill 8-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Nick Varner | 2000 U.S.Open Straight Pool |
| George Breedlove defeated Mike Sigel | 1994 Sands Regency Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Johnny Archer | 1993 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Tony Ellin defeated Mike Sigel | 1993 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 1993 Sands Regency Open 9-Ball |
| Johnny Archer defeated Mike Sigel | 1993 Sands Regency Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Mark Tadd | 1993 Sands Regency Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Keith McCready | 1993 Great 9-Ball Shootout 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Steve Mizerak | 1992 U.S.Open Straight Pool |
| Mike Sigel defeated Mike Zuglan | 1992 U.S.Open Straight Pool |
| Mike Sigel defeated Kim Davenport | 1992 Bicycle Club Invitational 9-Ball |
| Nick Varner defeated Mike Sigel | 1990 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Keith McCready | 1989 Golden Invitational $10,000 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Unknown Player | 1988 King of the Rings 9-Ball |
| Earl Strickland defeated Mike Sigel | 1988 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Buddy Hall | 1987 Peter Vitalie Invitaional 9-Ball |
| Mike Sigel defeated Louie Roberts | 1985 Challenge Match Of The Decade 9-Ball |
| Warren Costanza defeated Mike Sigel | 1979 World Pro-Am 9-Ball |