| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Cedric Lee defeated Nick Toulis | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Terry Snache defeated Nick Toulis | 2013 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Kevin Lazaro defeated Nick Toulis | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Kirk Nobes defeated Nick Toulis | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Jeff Pollock defeated Nick Toulis | 2010 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Scot Noonan defeated Nick Toulis | 2010 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Nick Toulis defeated Peter Hetherington | 2010 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Scot Noonan defeated Nick Toulis | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Nick Toulis defeated Aaryn Sheahan | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Nick Toulis defeated Steve Barnhart | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Tom Hogan defeated Nick Toulis | 2009 404 Tour 9-Ball |