| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Paul Pensgen defeated Vince Prinzivalli | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Mike Giurleo defeated Paul Pensgen | 2019 Turning Stone Classic XXXI 9-Ball |
| Paul Pensgen defeated Steven Smith | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Jayson Shaw defeated Paul Pensgen | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Marc Dionne defeated Paul Pensgen | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Paul Pensgen defeated Karl Kasprzak | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Paul Pensgen defeated Brandon Williams | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Paul Pensgen defeated David Ricci | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Sylvain Grenier defeated Paul Pensgen | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |
| Ron Casanzio defeated Paul Pensgen | 2015 Turning Stone Classic XXIII 9-Ball |