| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Paul Toddy defeated Jim House | 2024 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| David Jacobs defeated Paul Toddy | 2024 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Jay Pettlon defeated Paul Toddy | 2024 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated John Chapman | 2023 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated William Brannock | 2023 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Sergio Rivas defeated Paul Toddy | 2023 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Naoyuki Oi defeated Paul Toddy | 2023 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| David Brengle defeated Paul Toddy | 2022 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Robert Jones defeated Paul Toddy | 2022 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Tyrus Kelley defeated Paul Toddy | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Jeremy Brown | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Shane Van Boening defeated Paul Toddy | 2020 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Ed Williams | 2020 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Jayson Shaw defeated Paul Toddy | 2020 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Shannon Murphy defeated Paul Toddy | 2020 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| David Strawn Sr. defeated Paul Toddy | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Tim DeRuyter defeated Paul Toddy | 2019 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated James Beverly | 2018 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated J.D. Dolan | 2018 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Konrad Juszczyszyn defeated Paul Toddy | 2018 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Lee Van Corteza defeated Paul Toddy | 2018 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Ronald Roach | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Sky Woodward defeated Paul Toddy | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Rob Vogen defeated Paul Toddy | 2018 Derby City Classic Bank Pool |
| Paul Toddy defeated Raymond Galaviz | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Jose Aquino defeated Paul Toddy | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Mike Athens | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Andrew Garde | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Lawrence Everson defeated Paul Toddy | 2016 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Randy Hanson defeated Paul Toddy | 2016 Derby City Classic 9-Ball |
| Kenny Brunck defeated Paul Toddy | 2015 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| David Ferguson defeated Paul Toddy | 2014 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Mel Schuette | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Bader Al Awadi | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Dan Hau defeated Paul Toddy | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Damian Alishan defeated Paul Toddy | 2013 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Brad Ragon | 2012 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| Paul Toddy defeated Jeremy Sane | 2012 Derby City Classic One Pocket |
| David Grossman defeated Paul Toddy | 2012 Derby City Classic One Pocket |