| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Phil Tourangeau defeated Peter Menzel | 2024 TopShots 6th Anniversary 10-ball 10-Ball |
| Peter Menzel defeated Tyson Baudistel | 2023 Thanksgiving Fair Rate 9-Ball |
| Jayson Handugan defeated Peter Menzel | 2023 Thanksgiving Fair Rate 9-Ball |
| Warren Flett defeated Peter Menzel | 2023 Thanksgiving Fair Rate 9-Ball |
| Trevor Stanley defeated Peter Menzel | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 9-Ball |
| Mark Holtzclaw defeated Peter Menzel | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 9-Ball |
| Ron Loscheider defeated Peter Menzel | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 9-Ball |
| Bill Skrutsky defeated Peter Menzel | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 9-Ball |
| Peter Menzel defeated Shane Levitt | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 8-Ball |
| Peter Menzel defeated Mark Atkinson | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 8-Ball |
| Peter Menzel defeated Mitch Osting | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 8-Ball |
| Steve Frost defeated Peter Menzel | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 8-Ball |
| Robert Lasco defeated Peter Menzel | 2019 VNEA Las Vegas 8-Ball |