| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Daniel Kinkade defeated Randy Criswell | 2024 Friday Night with Calcutta 8-Ball |
| Randy Criswell defeated Joey Pickard | 2024 Friday Night with Calcutta 8-Ball |
| Mike Gillon defeated Randy Criswell | 2024 Friday Night with Calcutta 8-Ball |
| Randy Criswell defeated James Ellis | 2024 City Limits Monthly 8-Ball |
| Mitchell Thompson defeated Randy Criswell | 2024 City Limits Monthly 8-Ball |
| Randy Criswell defeated Shane Hopkins | 2024 City Limits Monthly 8-Ball |
| Mike Gillon defeated Randy Criswell | 2024 City Limits Monthly 8-Ball |
| David Ihben defeated Randy Criswell | 2023 JOBs Billiards / Jersey Girl Split Low side 9-Ball |
| Randy Criswell defeated Steve Beaulieu | 2023 JOBs Billiards / Jersey Girl Split Low side 9-Ball |