| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Ryan Clark defeated Robert Carlisle | 2009 PIOS - Event 8 Snooker |
| Adam Wicheard defeated Robert Carlisle | 2009 PIOS - Event 7 Snooker |
| David Craggs defeated Robert Carlisle | 2009 PIOS - Event 6 Snooker |
| Mitchell Mann defeated Robert Carlisle | 2008 PIOS - Event 5 Snooker |
| Jamie O'Neill defeated Robert Carlisle | 2008 PIOS - Event 4 Snooker |
| Robert Carlisle defeated Christopher Davis | 2008 PIOS - Event 4 Snooker |
| Shokat Ali defeated Robert Carlisle | 2008 PIOS - Event 3 Snooker |
| Neil Claycraft defeated Robert Carlisle | 2008 PIOS - Event 2 Snooker |
| David Portman defeated Robert Carlisle | 2008 PIOS - Event 1 Snooker |
| Robert Carlisle defeated Mark Livingstone | 2008 PIOS - Event 1 Snooker |