| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Terry Martin defeated Shay Smith | 2015 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Rod Arsenault defeated Shay Smith | 2014 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Jason Williams defeated Shay Smith | 2014 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Jeff Lohmer defeated Shay Smith | 2013 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Paul Duell defeated Shay Smith | 2013 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Paul Koeuth defeated Shay Smith | 2013 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Tim Aylward defeated Shay Smith | 2013 Royal City Challenge 9-Ball |
| Jeff Pollock defeated Shay Smith | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Shay Smith defeated Steve Scobie | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Dave Woods defeated Shay Smith | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Shay Smith defeated Mike Patrowicz | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Lee Brett defeated Shay Smith | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |
| Karl Kasprzak defeated Shay Smith | 2012 404 Tour 9-Ball |