| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Justin Astley defeated Toby Simpson | 2011 PTC - Event 11 Snooker |
| Andy Hicks defeated Toby Simpson | 2012 PTC - Event 1 Snooker |
| Toby Simpson defeated Ben Fortey | 2012 PTC - Event 1 Snooker |
| Adrian Gunnell defeated Toby Simpson | 2012 PTC - Event 2 Snooker |
| James Gillespie defeated Toby Simpson | 2012 PTC - Event 4 Snooker |