| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Barry McLean defeated Tony Labattaglia | 2007 Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Tony Labattaglia defeated Andrew Lamingman | 2007 Amateur Canadian Championships 9-Ball |
| Tony Labattaglia defeated Jeremy Metcalf | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Milton Strack defeated Tony Labattaglia | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |
| Chris Gentile defeated Tony Labattaglia | 2019 U.S. Amateur Championship |