| Result | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Tony Mathew defeated Clayton Marischen | 2024 Stixx Open Split R7/R5 on 1-6-2023 10-Ball |
| Tony Top defeated Tony Mathew | 2024 Stixx Open Split R7/R5 on 1-6-2023 10-Ball |
| Gavin Ray Mathew defeated Tony Mathew | 2024 Stixx Open Split R7/R5 on 1-6-2023 10-Ball |
| Tony Mathew defeated Neil Saidawi | 2024 Stixx Open Split R7/R5 on 1-6-2023 10-Ball |
| Tony Mathew defeated John Bergman | 2024 Stixx Open Split R7/R5 on 1-6-2023 10-Ball |
| Gary Hess defeated Tony Mathew | 2024 SHERMAN VFW TEXOMA SHOOTOUT - 13/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| Tony Sulsar defeated Tony Mathew | 2024 SHERMAN VFW TEXOMA SHOOTOUT - 13/JAN/23 9-Ball |
| Tony Mathew defeated Colby Burke | 2023 Stixx Open Handicapped on 12-30-2023 9-Ball |
| Max Sun defeated Tony Mathew | 2023 Stixx Open Handicapped on 12-30-2023 9-Ball |
| Tony Mathew defeated Robert Russell | 2023 Stixx Open Handicapped on 12-30-2023 9-Ball |
| Tony Mathew defeated John Askew | 2023 Stixx Open Handicapped on 12-30-2023 9-Ball |
| Johnny Cinco Garcia defeated Tony Mathew | 2023 Stixx Open Handicapped on 12-30-2023 9-Ball |
| Tony Mathew defeated Steve Deason | 2023 625 & Under Call 9-Ball |
| Mark Johnson defeated Tony Mathew | 2023 625 & Under Call 9-Ball |
| Mark Lawson defeated Tony Mathew | 2023 625 & Under Call 9-Ball |