| Brandon Shuff | Johnny Archer | 1 - Wins | 2 - Wins |
|---|
| Match | Tournament |
|---|---|
| Johnny Archer defeated Brandon Shuff | 2012 U.S.Open 9-Ball |
| Johnny Archer defeated Brandon Shuff | 2016 Turning Stone Classic XXV 9-Ball |
| Brandon Shuff defeated Johnny Archer | 2012 Diamond Players Championship 10-Ball |